I always appreciate the time to tear apart someone’s false comparison. In this case, it’s iPod vs. Zune again, and the comparison is courtesy of http://www.zunescene.com/comparison/.
So let’s get to it here. The first issue mentioned is price and storage, both equal across the board. The next two issues tackled are Wi-Fi and filesharing. First off, Wi-Fi isn’t needed on an MP3 player of any kind. Sure, it allows for some potentially cool features, but the Zune just puts it all to waste. Why have something there if it’s not going to be used? Oh, and it puts an ENORMOUS strain on the battery life. Why send out files that are DRMed? What if you made them yourself? And the RIAA must be having a fit over that. Until the Zune can utilize the WiFi with some meaningful features, the iPod takes the first two points in this battle, and on Battery life as well.
So far, iPod: 3, Zune: 0
The next issue is Landscape/Portrait mode. I’ll admit that the iPod needs a better screen in which to watch movies on. However, if you like spending to the tune of $500, the iPhone will cater to your needs just fine in this regard. Otherwise, Zune wins on this one.
iPod: 3, Zune: 1
Next is that of an FM tuner. The Zune has this one as well, since the good ol’ Zune includes one standard. The iPod does not, and instead you must pay $50 to get an FM tuner for an iPod. Chalk up another one to the Zune.
iPod: 3, Zune: 2
Preloaded Audio and Video: You know what? I’m not going to tackle this one, since if you bought a damned MP3 player, you probably already have music you want to throw on it.
Next, Zunescene mentions a “preloaded virus”. Jesus christ on a fourwheeler, this one’s in the past. IMO, I think this is just a cheap attempt to make the iPod look really bad in comparison to the Zune. But I won’t side with either on that dispute.
Now we have one so frivolous, and it amuses me that these people attempt to use this as something to poke at the iPod. Colors. Yesiree, colors. Zune has white, black, crap-err, brown, and baby pink. iPod has just black and white. Who in their right mind wants pink? And who wants a zune that resembles a piece of crap? And we all know where MS got black and white.
And now, Scroll wheel/tactile control. This is sort of funny; ZS says that the iPod has a “scroll wheel” (Erm, click wheel), and no tactile control. The iPod does indeed have tactile control, in the menu, back, forward, and play/pause keys. Someone didn’t do their research.
Need I say more? The zune fails in comparison to the iPod. But if MS got their act together, they could potentially whip Apple. I doubt they will, but whatever.